2021
Holden Groher Indiana University
Anthony Migliaccio Vanderbilt University
2020
Kaleb Corbutt University of Louisville
2019
Joe Wilkinson University of Louisville
Drew Taylor University of Southern Indiana
2018
Gabe Bierman Indiana University
Ben Metzinger University of Louisville
Garrett Schmeltz University of Louisville
Chase Rudy Purdue University
Sammy Barnett Indiana University
Andrew Arnold Bellarmine University
Trey Sweeney Eastern Illinois University
Garron Moffett Lipscomb University
Nathan Toone Vincennes University
Nick Parrish Bellarmine University
Byrson McNay University of Southern Indiana
Lucas McNew University of Southern Indiana
Caleb Meeks University of Evansvillle
2017
Brody Heil University of Louisville
Jake Lewis Eastern Kentucky University
Tanner Craig University of Evansville
Trevor Ricker University of Southern Indiana
Lane Miller Indiana University
Gavin Napier Indiana University
Gavin Sullivan University of Louisville
Jake Randa Western Kentucky University
Zeb Vermillion University of Arkansas
Caleb Balgaard Indiana University
Griffin McLarty College of Charleston
Matthew Higgins Bellarmine University
Evan Aders University of Evansville
Elijah Dunham Indiana University
Drew Ashley Indiana University
Reece Kleinhelter University of Southern Indiana
Connor Holden Murray State
Sammy Mudd University of Southern Indiana
Tyler Vogel Marian University
Riley Crean Indiana University
2016
Austin Dickey University of Louisville
Cal Krueger Indiana University
Daniel Fischer University of Louisville
David Ellis University of Evansville
Kenton Crews University of Evansville
Ian Ellis Olney Central College
Evan Jewell Olney Central College
Peyton Mattingly Olney Central College
Brett Marshall University of Kentucky
Logan Murphy Greenville College
Cody Razer Indiana University Southeast
Tim Redford Kaskaskia College
Riley Willbur Transylvania University
Seth Hagan Centre College
Jacob Bates Centre College